No Good Deed.... Bonuses and Overtime Calculation Lawsuits
The topic of Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) overtime violations came up several times during last week's Employment Law Symposium, hosted by the Mid-Cities Human Resources Association and sponsored by Imperative Information Group.
As this bizjournals.com article suggests, many employers don't understand all of the variables in calculating overtime, particularly in relation to bonuses. The small business in the article was sued for overtime violations by three employees after paying their employees a bonus for doing a good job. The employees alleged that the bonus increased their regular rate of pay and sued for the additional overtime due them for the period covered by the bonus. The business owners spent $400,000 defending the lawsuit before settling.
"The difference between the amount actually paid and the higher rate was trivial, but all the fees made it an exorbitant amount," said one of the owners.
Under the FLSA, non-discretionary bonuses such as might be paid out in pay-for-performance plans, change an employee's "regular rate" of pay retroactively. So, that $2,000 year-end bonus for meeting performance objectives may adjust the regular rate of pay for a full-time employee who worked 150 hours overtime during the year by 89¢ ($2,000 / 2,230 regular and overtime hours).
So, the employer is liable to the employee for one-half of the extra 89¢ for each overtime hour worked for a total of $133.50.
[NOTE: I had to double check my process with the DOL's website. Initially, I only applied the bonus to the hours that were regularly scheduled (assuming 40 hours per week), which resulted in a slightly higher "regular rate" and a higher overtime rate. I believe some states' own wage and hour laws may calculate bonus overtime this way.]
Performance-based bonuses are probably still preferable to many other compensation schemes in a tight economy, but employers need to plan ahead to make sure they don't have to defend a lawsuit next year due to the impact of this year's bonus.

Like every other department, human resources managers are being asked to measure the effectiveness of their activities and report their impact on the organization's bottom line.
In this episode of The Imperative Podcast, Mike interviews Dr. Lee Colan, a researcher and business consultant, and author of nine books including 7 Moments That Define Excellent Leaders and Engaging the Hearts and Minds of All Your Employees: How to Ignite Passionate Performance for Better Business Results.
In this edition of the Imperative Podcast, Mike Coffey interviews Lon Williams, who will be speaking at the September 3rd 